Best Island in Fish It: Complete Location Guide

Choosing the right island to fish at in Fish It can make the difference between struggling with starter gear and rapidly progressing through the game. Each island in this popular Roblox fishing simulator offers unique fish species, different rarity pools, and varying profitability levels. But which island should you prioritize for your current stage of the game?

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll break down every major island in Fish It, rank them by their value for different goals, and help you determine the absolute best island for your fishing journey.

Best Fishing Spots in Fish It

Understanding Island Progression in Fish It

Fish It features multiple distinct fishing locations, each designed for different stages of player progression. Understanding this progression system is crucial for maximizing your efficiency and earnings.

The game starts you at Fisherman Island (formerly Stingray Shores), but savvy players quickly realize that staying there isn’t optimal for growth. Each island offers different fish rarities, average values, and special opportunities that make some locations far superior to others.

The Best Island in Fish It: Kohana Volcano

For the vast majority of players, especially those in early to mid-game, Kohana Volcano is hands-down the best island in Fish It. This volcanic fishing spot offers the perfect combination of accessibility, profitability, and farming efficiency that makes it essential for rapid progression.

Why Kohana Volcano Dominates

Kohana Volcano allows you to catch Magma Goby frequently, which are significantly more valuable than most fish you’ll encounter with early-game rods. The fish pool here is exceptionally profitable because even the common catches sell for good money compared to other early locations.

Key advantages of Kohana Volcano:

• High-value common fish: Even your frequent catches sell well
• Free upgraded rod: The Lava Fisherman NPC gives you a free Lava Rod with better luck stats than starter equipment
• Accessible early: You only need 50 Gold to buy a boat and reach the island
• Efficient farming: Fast catch rates mean more money per hour
• Rare fish opportunities: Mythic Blueflame Ray (1 in 93,000) and Legendary Lavafin Tuna (1 in 9,999) offer massive payouts when you get lucky

How to Reach Kohana Volcano

Getting to Kohana Volcano should be your first major goal in Fish It:

1. Save 50 Gold: Fish at Fisherman Island until you have enough for a boat
2. Purchase a boat: Buy it from the shop on Fisherman Island
3. Sail to Kohana Island: Navigate across the ocean to the larger volcanic island
4. Find the volcano entrance: Near the village, locate the path leading into the volcano
5. Talk to the Lava Fisherman: Receive your free Lava Rod to boost your fishing effectiveness

This investment pays for itself within minutes of fishing at the volcano due to the dramatically increased fish values.

Complete Fish It Island Tier List

Different islands serve different purposes throughout your Fish It journey. Here’s how all the major locations stack up:

S-Tier Islands: Essential Destinations

Kohana Volcano

• Best for: Early to mid-game money farming
• Special feature: Free Lava Rod from NPC
• Average value: Very high for progression stage
• Fish pool: 8 species including valuable Mythic and Legendary catches

Esoteric Depths

• Best for: Farming Enchant Stones and late-game fishing
• Special feature: Enchantment Altar for rod upgrades
• Average value: High
• Fish pool: 8 species with good Legendary drop rates

Tropical Grove

• Best for: Enchant Stone farming with 1 in 1,000 chance
• Special feature: Excellent drop rates for valuable items
• Average value: Moderate to high
• Fish pool: 3 documented species, safe AFK spot

A-Tier Islands: Solid Options

Coral Reefs

• Best for: Mid-game progression with diverse catches
• Average value: Good
• Fish pool: 15 species including multiple Legendary options
• Notable catches: Hawks Turtle (Mythic, 1 in 75,000), Blue Lobster (Legendary, 1 in 25,000)

Kohana Island (Village)

• Best for: Transitional fishing between starter and volcano
• Average value: Moderate
• Fish pool: 15 species with decent variety
• Notable catches: Prismy Seahorse (Mythic, 1 in 88,000), Loggerhead Turtle (Mythic, 1 in 55,000)

B-Tier Islands: Situational Value

Ocean Fishing

• Best for: Traveling between islands, specific rare fish
• Average value: Moderate
• Fish pool: 16 species
• Notable catches: Hammerhead Shark (Mythic, 1 in 99,999), Manta Ray (Mythic, 1 in 50,000)

Crater Island

• Best for: Alternative fishing spot with unique species
• Average value: Low to moderate
• Fish pool: 7 species, mostly uncommon and rare

C-Tier Islands: Limited Use

Fisherman Island (Stingray Shores)

• Best for: Absolute beginners, accessing shops and services
• Average value: Low
• Fish pool: 18 species but mostly low-value commons
• Why to leave quickly: Better money farming exists at Kohana Volcano

Island Strategies by Player Progression

Your ideal fishing island changes as you progress through Fish It. Here’s how to optimize your location choices:

Early Game Strategy (Levels 1-10)

Primary location: Kohana Volcano

Get to Kohana Volcano as quickly as possible after buying your first boat. The investment of 50 Gold pays for itself immediately, and you’ll earn money 3-5 times faster than at Fisherman Island.

Action plan:

1. Fish at Fisherman Island only until you have 50 Gold
2. Buy a boat immediately
3. Sail directly to Kohana Island
4. Get your free Lava Rod from the Lava Fisherman NPC
5. Fish exclusively at Kohana Volcano until you can afford better rods

Mid Game Strategy (Levels 10-25)

Primary locations: Kohana Volcano, Coral Reefs, Tropical Grove

At this stage, you have multiple viable options depending on your goals:

• For pure money: Continue at Kohana Volcano for consistent earnings
• For Enchant Stones: Split time between Tropical Grove and Esoteric Depths
• For variety and collection: Explore Coral Reefs for diverse species

Action plan:

1. Upgrade your rod when possible
2. Start collecting Enchant Stones at Tropical Grove
3. Visit Esoteric Depths to enchant your best rods
4. Return to Kohana Volcano for money farming between upgrades

Late Game Strategy (Level 25+)

Primary locations: Esoteric Depths, Tropical Grove, specialized farming

End-game players should focus on:

• Enchant Stone farming: Tropical Grove and Esoteric Depths for rod enhancements
• Rare fish hunting: Specific islands for collection completion
• Optimal farming routes: Multiple islands for maximum efficiency

Action plan:

1. Maintain enchanted rods for all situations
2. Farm Enchant Stones consistently at Tropical Grove
3. Hunt specific Mythic fish at their optimal islands
4. Maximize luck with bobbers, enchantments, and weather conditions

Island-Specific Fish Values and ROI

Understanding the profitability of each island helps you make informed fishing decisions:

Kohana Volcano Fish Value Analysis

The volcano’s fish pool is designed for profitability:

• Magma Goby (Uncommon, 1 in 55): Your bread and butter catch, excellent value for frequency
• Lava Butterfly (Uncommon, 1 in 125): Solid secondary catch
• Volsail Tang (Rare, 1 in 300): Decent boost to hourly earnings
• Lavafin Tuna (Legendary, 1 in 9,999): Massive payday when caught
• Blueflame Ray (Mythic, 1 in 93,000): Ultimate jackpot catch

The average value per cast at Kohana Volcano significantly exceeds Fisherman Island and matches or beats most other locations until the absolute end-game.

Esoteric Depths Value Analysis

Esoteric Depths balances fish value with Enchant Stone opportunities:

• Enchant Stone (Epic, 1 in 2,900): Primary reason to fish here
• Enchanted Angelfish (Legendary, 1 in 5,000): Excellent value
• Magic Tang (Legendary, 1 in 7,500): Strong earnings
• Abyss Seahorse (Mythic, 1 in 95,000): Top-tier catch

The dual benefit of profitable fish AND Enchant Stones makes this a premier end-game location.

Coral Reefs Value Analysis

Coral Reefs offers the highest diversity but moderate average value:

• Multiple Legendary options: Four different Legendary species
• Hawks Turtle (Mythic, 1 in 75,000): Most common Mythic location
• Varied uncommon catches: Consistent moderate earnings
• Collection completion: Best for filling your fish index

Good for variety seekers but not optimal for pure money farming.

Special Features and Hidden Secrets by Island

Some islands offer unique benefits beyond their fish pools:

Fisherman Island Secrets

A hidden cave around the island contains a pond where you can catch the Epic Unicorn Tang (1 in 4,500), along with higher-rarity species that sell for premium prices. Explore thoroughly to find this secret spot.

Esoteric Depths Utilities

Beyond fishing, Esoteric Depths houses the crucial Enchantment Altar. Pay the 400 Coin elevator fee to access the underground chamber where you can apply enchantments to your rods using Enchant Stones.

Weather and Time Bonuses

Certain islands benefit from specific conditions:

• Night fishing: Increases luck on most islands
• Rain events: Boost catch rates significantly
• Fishing radar: Shows boosted areas on your map for targeted farming

Common Island Mistakes to Avoid

Players often make these location-based errors that slow their progression:

Staying at Fisherman Island Too Long

The biggest mistake new players make is grinding at the starter island instead of immediately moving to Kohana Volcano. Those 50 Gold for a boat might seem expensive initially, but staying at Fisherman Island costs you far more in lost earnings.

The fix: Buy a boat as your absolute first purchase, even before upgrading your rod. The increased earnings at Kohana Volcano will let you afford better equipment much faster.

Ignoring Enchant Stone Farming

Mid-game players often focus exclusively on money farming and neglect Enchant Stone collection. This creates a bottleneck when you finally want to enchant your high-tier rods.

The fix: Dedicate at least 20-30% of your fishing time to Tropical Grove or Esoteric Depths once you reach mid-game. Having 5-10 Enchant Stones in reserve prevents progression delays.

Random Island Hopping

Constantly switching islands without a plan reduces your efficiency. Travel time between locations represents zero earnings, and you lose momentum by not optimizing any single spot.

The fix: Choose your primary island based on your current goal (money, Enchant Stones, or specific fish) and commit to that location for extended sessions. Only switch when you’ve accomplished your objective.

Overlooking Free Equipment

The Lava Fisherman at Kohana Volcano gives you a free Lava Rod, yet many players miss this because they rush to the volcano without talking to NPCs.

The fix: Always explore new areas thoroughly and talk to every NPC. Free upgrades dramatically accelerate your progression.

Fishing Without Bobbers

Bobbers (bait) significantly increase your luck stat, mutation chances, and shiny chances. Fishing without them at premium islands wastes the location’s potential.

The fix: Always equip appropriate bobbers for your target catches. The increased rare fish rate easily offsets the bobber cost.

Advanced Island Optimization Techniques

Once you understand the basics, these advanced strategies maximize your island efficiency:

Multi-Island Rotation Farming

Create a rotation between complementary islands:

1. 30 minutes at Kohana Volcano: Pure money farming
2. 20 minutes at Tropical Grove: Enchant Stone hunting
3. 10 minutes at Esoteric Depths: Enchant Stones and valuable fish
4. Repeat cycle: Balanced progression

This rotation ensures steady money income while building your Enchant Stone reserve.

Weather-Specific Island Targeting

Different weather conditions favor different islands:

• Rain: Fish at locations with Stormhunter-boosted catches
• Night: Target islands with rare night-exclusive species
• Clear weather: Focus on your primary farming island

Adapting to weather maximizes your hourly value.

Collection Completion Strategy

When hunting specific fish for collection completion:

1. Identify your needed species: Check which fish you’re missing
2. Cross-reference island fish pools: Find where they spawn
3. Optimize for that specific island: Use appropriate rods, bobbers, and enchantments
4. Farm during optimal conditions: Target beneficial weather or time of day

This targeted approach completes collections faster than random fishing.

AFK Island Selection

For AFK fishing sessions, prioritize safe, profitable islands:

• Tropical Grove: Safe AFK spot for coins and Enchant Stones
• Kohana Volcano: Consistent value even during AFK
• Avoid: Open ocean or areas with travel hazards

AFK fishing should still generate meaningful progress, so island choice matters.

Island Unlock Requirements and Costs

Understanding access requirements helps you plan your progression:

Immediate Access (No Requirements)

• Fisherman Island: Starting location
• Ocean: Accessible with any boat

Early Access (50-100 Gold)

• Kohana Island: 50 Gold boat required
• Kohana Volcano: Boat + finding entrance on Kohana Island

Mid-Game Access (Better Equipment)

• Coral Reefs: Better boat and navigation
• Tropical Grove: Mid-game boat

Late-Game Access (400+ Gold Investment)

• Esoteric Depths: 400 Gold elevator fee per visit

Budget for these access costs when planning your progression path.

Fishing Location FAQ

What’s the best island for beginners in Fish It?

For absolute beginners, start at Fisherman Island only until you have 50 Gold, then immediately move to Kohana Volcano. The volcano offers dramatically better money farming and includes a free upgraded rod.

Where should I farm Enchant Stones?

Tropical Grove is the best spot for Enchant Stone farming, with Esoteric Depths as a strong alternative that also offers valuable fish.

Which island has the most valuable fish?

Esoteric Depths and Kohana Volcano both feature high-value fish pools. Esoteric Depths has better Legendary drop rates, while Kohana Volcano offers more consistent valuable catches.

Should I ever return to Fisherman Island?

Only return to Fisherman Island for shop access, selling fish, or catching the secret Unicorn Tang in the hidden cave. It’s not a good farming location after early game.

What’s the fastest way to get rich in Fish It?

Rush to Kohana Volcano as early as possible, get the free Lava Rod, and farm there consistently. Use your earnings to upgrade your rod and bobbers, then maintain your focus on high-value islands like Kohana Volcano and Esoteric Depths.

Maximize Your Fishing Success

The best island in Fish It ultimately depends on your current goals and progression stage, but Kohana Volcano stands out as the single most important location for rapid advancement. Its combination of accessibility, profitability, and free equipment makes it the cornerstone of every successful player’s strategy.

Start by reaching Kohana Volcano as quickly as possible, then expand to Tropical Grove and Esoteric Depths as you progress. Master these three locations, and you’ll have everything you need to become a fishing tycoon in Fish It.